2x MORE Subscribers From 2.5x LESS Views: Why

I made a video about Steve Jobs.

It got 911,600 views on YouTube Shorts.

Added 299 subscribers to my YouTube channel.

The entertaining YouTube Short: 911,000 views and 299 added subscribers to my YouTube channel.

I made a video about how ChatGPT was being used to manipulate Google.

It got 374,000 views on YouTube Shorts.

Added 556 subscribers to my YouTube channel.

The useful YouTube Short: 374,000 views and 556 added subscribers to my YouTube channel.

2.5x less views, 2x more subscribers.

I gave the two transcripts to Claude.

I said, what do you think the reasons are for the discrepancy in subscribers per views?

I’m going to summarize this in a moment but here was Claude’s output, for anybody curious:

Claude's answer to: What do you think the reasons are for the discrepancy in subscribers per views? "Looking at your two videos, there's a clear difference in subscriber conversion rates: Steve Jobs video: 299 subscribers from 911,000 views = 0.033% conversion rate ChatGPT/Google video: 556 subscribers from 374,000 views = 0.149% conversion rate The ChatGPT video converted nearly 5x better. Here are the likely reasons: Content Type & Audience Intent The ChatGPT video provides actionable, technical information that viewers can immediately use. People searching for SEO tactics or ChatGPT tips are actively looking to learn and implement strategies - they're more likely to subscribe for future tutorials. The Steve Jobs video, while engaging, is more of a "did you know" story that satisfies curiosity without creating a strong need for follow-up content. Niche Authority & Expectation Setting The ChatGPT video positions you as someone who understands digital marketing, SEO, and AI tools - establishing expertise in a specific, valuable niche. Viewers think "this person knows insider tricks I want to learn." The Steve Jobs story, while well-told, doesn't clearly signal what other content you might create. Value Proposition Clarity After watching the ChatGPT video, viewers can easily imagine what subscribing would get them: more digital marketing insights, SEO tips, AI tool tutorials. The Steve Jobs video doesn't create as clear an expectation about your channel's focus. Audience Quality vs Quantity The Steve Jobs video likely attracted a broader, more casual audience through YouTube's algorithm, while the ChatGPT video probably reached a more targeted audience actively interested in that specific topic. Smaller, more targeted audiences often convert better than large, general ones. The key insight: tutorial/educational content with clear practical value tends to drive higher subscriber conversion than pure storytelling content, even if the stories get more total views."

It comes down to this.

The Steve Jobs video was purely entertaining.

The SEO video was useful.

  1. Is it clear what the viewer/reader/listener should do next?
  2. Is it obvious why this information is useful?
  3. Could someone get a result or improvement just from this advice?

Making entertaining videos is nice. It feels good to make the content that you want to make and I would recommend doing that.

But – and I learned this six weeks ago when I had an even greater outcome – if you want people to remember you, to trust you, to come back to you… be useful.

If you’re looking for SEO that’s useful

Most SEOs peddle blog SEO which drives cold leads for a lot of work… not useful.

My 13.5 hour SEO course is the opposite – conversion-based SEO landing pages, far less words per page, less backlinks required, targeting HOT searchers – people looking with intent.

If you want an SEO method that’s actually useful for getting paying customers, users, and warm leads 👉https://edwardsturm.com/compact-keywords/

Keep learning

Get Ed’s top-secret marketing hacks in your inbox every week 👇

Picture of Edward Sturm

Edward Sturm

Edward Sturm is an entrepreneur, SEO, writer, and video producer.

Recent articles

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Get Ed's top-secret marketing hacks in your inbox every week.

Edward Sturm's growth hacking newsletter